|
Back
Which Tosca? New York Carnegie Hall 11/13/2026 - & November 15, 2026 Giacomo Puccini: Tosca Marina Rebeka (Tosca), Jonas Kaufmann (Cavaradossi), Ludovic Tézier (Scarpia), Andrew Moore (Angelotti), Ben Brady (Sacristan), Ben Reisinger (Spoletta), Benjamin Taylor (Sciarrone), Christopher Humbert Jr. (Jailer), Hugo Martínez‑Nieto (Shepherd)
New York Philharmonic Chorus, Malcolm J. Merriweather (director), Brooklyn Youth Chorus, Dianne Berkun Menaker (director), New York Philharmonic, Gustavo Dudamel (conductor)
“Which Tosca?” is the arch question musical New York has been asking lately. Normally, one would only hear Tosca at the Metropolitan Opera, where it has a mammoth run of 25 performances this season in Sir David McVicar’s production, a traditional effort that resembles the beloved Franco Zeffirelli staging of memory. But as the Met’s offerings dwindle–this season to just 17 productions, the smallest number since that struggling company’s 1966‑1967 season–other houses are picking up the slack.
Concert opera is far from unknown at Carnegie Hall, where the now‑defunct Opera Orchestra of New York long performed, and where the American Symphony Orchestra, the Boston Symphony, and other ensembles still sometimes give non‑staged operas. In March 2027, however, the venue will see its first complete performance of Richard Wagner’s four‑part Ring Cycle, from Opernhaus Zürich. This month, the New York Philharmonic leans into the effort with two performances of Tosca featuring star performers in the leading roles and an entire soloist cast making their Carnegie Hall debuts. Offered on a Friday evening and Sunday afternoon over the same weekend, they sandwiched a Saturday evening staged performance at the Met.
Gustavo Dudamel’s long-anticipated arrival as the New York Philharmonic’s new music director this season drove much of the buzz. Commanding sold‑out performances as far into the future as next June, his initial concerts have been wildly popular and seem to have transformed the orchestra from what many regarded as a sluggish cousin of the rest of New York’s musical world to a powerhouse of heretofore unlocked energy. From the first chords signaling the opera’s opening–the menacing theme identifying Scarpia, Rome’s hated police and Tosca’s villain–whatever miracle Dudamel has worked in rehearsal was on full display. The orchestra played with absolute symphonic unity while the conductor drove all before him to draw a rousing performance.
The soloists all have international reputations and stood out here in different ways. Much attention came to the robust German tenor Jonas Kaufmann, who added spice to the scheduling drama with an announcement earlier this year that he will no longer sing at the Met, in part due to its pandemic‑era treatment of artists. The Met’s loss was Carnegie’s gain as he delivered the role of the doomed but heroic Cavaradossi with a sturdy, almost baritonal timbre that he focused down to sweet pianos in the character’s two big arias. Marina Rebeka is better known in Europe, where she has dazzled critics for years in heavier Italian dramatic soprano parts. Her Tosca came off a bit cool and lacked some of the charm and playfulness that other singers brought to the role, but the performance was strong. Ludovic Tézier was a stentorian and menacing Scarpia. Dudamel brought it all together with energy and drive.
Paul du Quenoy
|